Login | Signup

COMMENT | 3-1 to Sony? Microsoft need a new console, and soon

Matt Gardner
Games consoles, Microsoft, Phil Spencer, PS4, Sony, Xbox One, Xbox One Slim

COMMENT | 3-1 to Sony? Microsoft need a new console, and soon

But not necessarily that new

Regardless of whether or not the sales figures for the last financial quarter are of consoles sold or shipped, regardless of the extent to which the PlayStation and Xbox numbers were muddied by last-gen console statistics, one thing is clear: Microsoft are lagging behind. By an alarming factor of three-to-one.

It's early days, of course, in terms of Phil Spencer's tenure at the top. For much of 2014, he's been dealing in damage control, and trying to turn the omnishambles that Mattrick left behind into something identifiable, something relatable, something to do with games rather than every other facet of entertainment.

COMMENT | 3-1 to Sony? Microsoft need a new console, and soon

It's clear that communication has hurt the Xbox One significantly. I posited in my recent article about Destiny that Sony have done a fantastic job in selling the idea "better on PS4". We've said since the two consoles launched that Microsoft have had the better exclusives thus far. We've suggested that they have the better exclusive lineup this Christmas, what with the Master Chief Collection, Sunset Overdrive, and Forza Horizon 2 edging LittleBigPlanet 3, Driveclub, and (if it's even still on track for this year) PlanetSide 2. But as Nintendo have found out to their cost, you can have some of the finest first-party exclusives around, but third-party games matter. A lot.

Last year we also stressed the importance of communication. Sony's message has been clear from day on: the PS4 is #fortheplayers. It's a games console designed to play games, be easy to develop for,squeeze out as much power as possible for as low a price as can be had, while maintaining the standard of quality that we've come to expect from PlayStation devices. By contrast, the Xbox One was first unveiled as being all about entertainment, TV, and sports. Then it was an all-in-one console -- "Xbox One. Input One". Now it's had Kinect chopped off, and Microsoft's in-house entertainment production unit is closing its doors.COMMENT | 3-1 to Sony? Microsoft need a new console, and soon

E3, however, was emblematic of Phil Spencer hitting the reset button. But it wasn't enough. The Xbox One is still a confusing mess of a console, seemingly less powerful than its cheaper rival, having made optional a device that was pretty integral to the console's UI but was only ever going to be as successful as the games tailored towards its unique capabilities. It's focus as an HTPC is rapidly becoming more redundant as smart TVs improve in performance and come down in price, and the HDMI passthrough is a quirky, but ultimately pointless feature for the majority of the gaming audience.

Put simply, if Spencer is to perform a proper reset of the Xbox One brand and realign the console's focus on gaming, he's going to need a new console to do it. Not a generational console, but an Xbox One trimmed of all the fat. One that gets rid of everything apart from the core system hardware and a big fat hard-drive.

COMMENT | 3-1 to Sony? Microsoft need a new console, and soon

The gimmicks clearly aren't shifting Xbox One units, but the games could, given the right environment. Slim consoles are always something of a slap in the face to early adopters, but for the sake of prospective buyers -- and here I'm being selfish and thinking about myself too as a would-be Xbox One buyer -- Microsoft shouldn't let that stop them in producing a console geared entirely towards gaming and little else. By getting rid of the superfluous elements, Microsoft would surely be able to produce a console that, okay, might still cede something by way of pure grunt to the PS4, but could reasonably be expected to undercut the competition in terms of price.

Jon and I had a lengthy discussion about this in recording this week's Game Buzz (you can catch it in its entirety on Saturday) and he said something that was really rather damning about the amount of hardware bloat on the Xbox One: has there ever been another point in gaming history where the technically weaker console in terms of power and performance has proven more expensive? It's simply not right, and although Microsoft have made concessions to this fact by making Kinect optional, they haven't gone far enough. They need to create a proper Xbox One Slim (Xbox Prime? Xbox Basic? Xbox Solus?) that removes everything but the essentials, giving consumers the opportunity to really choose, and making clear to their confused public that if all they want are games, they don't have to pay for other extraneous features.

COMMENT | 3-1 to Sony? Microsoft need a new console, and soon

E3 was the dawn of a new chapter for Xbox, but Spencer and co. need to stop saying things like "we still really believe in Kinect" having just doomed the already ailing device to a life of being an afterthought by making it optional. Microsoft have started out on the road to slimming down their focus when it comes to the Xbox mission statement. Now they have to put the console itself on a diet.

Add a comment11 comments
pandpand  Aug. 1, 2014 at 13:26

Stupid question of the day:
Is Game Buzz a podcast - and if so what is the RSS feed ?

MattGardner  Aug. 1, 2014 at 13:51

Lol, not a stupid question at all :)

It is indeed our weekly podcast that goes live pretty much every Saturday. You can click here or the banner on the front page to see all of the Game Buzz posts here onsite, we publish each podcast on YouTube as well and you can find those here, and click here for the RSS feed.

pandpand  Aug. 1, 2014 at 14:25

Excellent. Thanks Matt.

snotters  Aug. 2, 2014 at 10:12

Can you use "Xbox one 360" controllers on the "ps plus" please.

Govkviviv  Aug. 2, 2014 at 12:02

The XB1 will do just fine. The streaming service will come out and the cloud will do all the wonderful things the PS4 equivalent can't. Games will sell the XB1, not resolutions.

Dnice704  Aug. 2, 2014 at 12:21

Seem like people are over looking the situation and trying make a big deal out of this. The 3:1 ratio isn't ps4 vs Xbox one at all. The ratio represent the first quarter sale of the PS4,ps3 and ps2 vs Xbox one and Xbox 360 and yes I said the ps2. Sony also went on the record to state this and did not provide individual number for each console. The also stated that the ps3 wasn't sell as the expected. So majority of those sell could just be ps4 and ps2. Another thing these are global sales. The ps4 to the ps2 are all global. The Xbox 360 is global but the Xbox one is no where near close with all this factoring in you can't say they need a new console based off that information. In 6 months if nothing has change I might agree with you but for now your jumping the gun

ShowanW  Aug. 2, 2014 at 14:30

This article is horrendous. Coming from a person who doesn't even own the console. Bloat?!?!?!?.... smh.... go to the X1 and show me bloat.

As much as Mattrick was a screw up he was right. If you don't like change stick with the 360 or get a PS4 (which I also happen to own).

After reading this article all you want is a last gen console with a better graphics card.

Sad... I want to see something new, boundries pushed?

I personally love Kinect, and will not be disconnecting it at any point in time.

Another post about Xbox that isn't saying anything, vying for clicks.

corvusmd  Aug. 2, 2014 at 20:42

Can someone please copy and past this article so we can revisit this in a year and laugh?

VegasDawg  Aug. 3, 2014 at 00:13

The XB1 will do just fine. The streaming service will come out and the cloud will do all the wonderful things the PS4 equivalent can't. Games will sell the XB1, not resolutions.

Playstion now is Sony's cloud. There will/is very little difference between consoles, especially now that both are starting to put out 1080p at 60fps. Just play the games you like and ignore ignorant fanBOYs.

hhbd  Aug. 3, 2014 at 07:17

I Don't agree. I own an X1 and a 360 (both with Kinect). To be honest I only used the kinect in the 360 for Dance Central, but the kinect in the X1 is much better, I really don´t imagine using a console without the commands Kinect in X1 does. Updates in X1 have been coming monthly and most of them are great, improving the experience a lot. I say, give it more time, to soon to make that statement. And remember X1 is gonna launch in China soon, I guess that's going to increase global numbers a lot.

Doymc  Aug. 3, 2014 at 12:54

He is right. The PS4 is the superior machine. I gave up my Xbox360 for the new PS4 and it was the right call. I do miss the exclusive content games like Halo but Destiny looks to make up for that.

Email Address:

You don't need an account to comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.