Login | Signup

Kickstarter Co-Founder Warns That Stretch Goals Can Be Dangerous

Author:
Jonathan Lester
Category:
News
Tags:
Kickstarter, Stretch goals

Kickstarter Co-Founder Warns That Stretch Goals Can Be Dangerous

"Tread Carefully"

In the wake of numerous crowd funding campaigns being delayed due to a slew of overly ambitious (if not irresponsible) stretch goals, Kickstarter boss Yancey Strickler warns that carelessly promising too much can irreparably damage a project.

Stretch goals, in case you don't know, are extra features that developers promise to add to a game if they raise extra funds above their Kickstarter target (we're talking about videogames here, naturally, though all Kickstarter projects can offer stretch goals). They often manage to convince more people to back it and kick in extra capital, but can lead to all manner of problems.

“What if someone got in early and helped a project reach its funding goal, but now the creator is focused on stretch goals?" Strickler posits in a Kickstarter blog post. "What if someone backs a project for a stretch goal-related reward, and that goal isn’t met? Both are bad experiences for backers.

“For a typical stretch goal a creator will promise to release their game in additional formats or add extra functions if certain funding goals are hit. But expanding a project’s scope can change the creative vision and put the whole project at risk. We’ve seen stretch goals leave some projects overwhelmed, over-budget, and behind schedule.”

Strickler explains that what developers see as "extra money" won't go as far as they think. Much of it will have to be spent on fulfilling backer rewards such as clothing and merchandise, whereas practically all projects require more money than intitally intended. As much as anything, this extra capital can simply be spent on polishing the existing product or just invested back into the company as profit, after delivering on the initial pitch.

“Many Kickstarter projects end up significantly overfunded, and creators often use those funds to improve the project’s end product.", he continued. "More funding might mean higher-quality materials and other improvements that thank backers with a better-made thing. For other creators overfunding means the project turns a profit. Both are great outcomes.

“Stretch goals, on the other hand, trade long-term risk for a short-term gain. Tread carefully.”

This echoes comments made by Zeboyd Games' Robert Boyd earlier this year, who warned that "feature bloat" (sometimes known as 'scope creep') is capable of derailing and delaying games - annoying backers in the process.

Double Fine's Broken Age recently came under fire for its two-part split and delay, though to be fair, stretch goals were technically never part of the plan (it never even really had a plan for better and worse). However, the likes of Project Eternity have taken on an enormous number of extra promises, and will need to deliver. We reckon that Project Phoenix should bear this in mind over the coming month.

Regular reader DivideByZero recently penned a community corner article about the state of Kickstarter, exploring several of these issues. You should read it. It's brilliant.

Add a comment2 comments
monkey13  Aug. 15, 2013 at 08:59

Warning from founder that what everyone has been doing is not a good idea. Bit late for that when devs have already taken millions from people.

Looks like the founder has spotted how this is going to end. With the majority of projects not delivering what they promised.

JonLester  Aug. 15, 2013 at 09:10

It was about time that someone senior stepped in IMO. Stretch goals have made any number of projects suffer - remember, games are just a small part of what Kickstarter supports - either causing massive delays or total derailments.

There's nothing wrong with them in theory. The problem is that asking for and promising too much is human nature, and stretch goals make it all too easy to get carried away and promise the earth.

Last edited by JonLester, Aug. 15, 2013 at 09:14

Email Address:

You don't need an account to comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.