Login | Signup

Sports Interactive Spied On Football Manager Pirates With Booby-Trapped Crack, Collected IP Addresses

Author:
Jonathan Lester
Category:
News
Tags:
Football Manager 2013, Piracy, Sega, Sports Interactive

Sports Interactive Spied On Football Manager Pirates With Booby-Trapped Crack, Collected IP Addresses

You couldn't make this up. The widely-distributed cracked version of Football Manager 2013 contained a flaw that automatically connected to Sports Interactive's servers, allowing them to record the IP address of everyone who played it. They've now published their findings, as opposed to sending round big strapping lads with cricket bats.

Sports Interactive studio director Miles Jacobson discussed the bizarre situation during a London Games Conference presentation today, the results of which were emailed to Dealspwn.com. The team used various analytical tools to compile an accurate picture of how many gamers pirated Football Manager 2013, and how much money they might have lost had the cracked version been made available on day one.

In terms of legitimate purchases and activations, the magic number was 1,184,652, well over a third of which occurred right here in the UK. Break out the bunting!

Sports Interactive Spied On Football Manager Pirates With Booby-Trapped Crack, Collected IP Addresses

Football Manager 2013 remained uncracked until May 12th, 2013, after which the pirated version started doing the rounds. Due to the aforementioned flaw, it "called home" upon activation... revealing that over 10,000,000 players had opted to download it for free - and that 1.8 million users played it five times or more. In the following table, Sports Interactive demonstrates that legal activations plummeted in all but two territories following its distribution.

Sports Interactive Spied On Football Manager Pirates With Booby-Trapped Crack, Collected IP Addresses

Sports Interactive also estimated what might have happened given the best and worst case scenarios: i.e. had the cracked version never released, or had released on day one. The financial difference between the two is a whopping $3,700,000. I'll let Jacobson show his working:

In the period since the illegal version became available, the overall legitimate activation rate has fallen by 17 per cent. Our calculations suggest that 1.74 per cent of illegal downloaders would purchase the game if no cracked version was available.

We believe that Football Manager 2013 enjoyed an uplift of 144,000 units prior to the crack and lost a potential 32,000 extra sales post-crack. Therefore, the difference between the game never being cracked and being cracked on day one can be calculated as 176,000 in unit sales or, in financial terms, a potential variance of $3,700,000 in net revenue.

Sorry, that was a lot of maths for a Thursday afternoon. Either way, it's clear that piracy is still a major issue for many developers and publishers... but is it a battle worth fighting when the most devastating DRM weapons either punish legitimate consumers or end up circumvented anyway?

Add a comment11 comments
Late  Nov. 14, 2013 at 14:12

Stick more booby-traps into games.
Was it Serious Sam that put you up against an unkillable beastie at one point if you were playing a hacked version of the game? I want more of that!

Quietus  Nov. 14, 2013 at 15:19

Yes, it was Serious Sam.:D

Quietus  Nov. 14, 2013 at 15:19

Yes, it was Serious Sam.:D

DivideByZero  Nov. 14, 2013 at 16:13

Or the Game Dev Tycoon where if you pirate the game, people pirate yours.

The one single thing people don't take in to account in these things though is, if it was a choice between pirating the game for free vs. paying for it... how many people would not have bothered at all and never played it if they had to pay for it?

Out of interest, do they offer a demo of the game?

JonLester  Nov. 14, 2013 at 16:33

@DivideByZero: Actually, they have taken that into account: "Our calculations suggest that 1.74 per cent of illegal downloaders would purchase the game if no cracked version was available."

That might not sound like much, but we're talking about a percentage of over 10 million copies.

There was a demo IIRC - it let us play half a season.

@Quietus: Yeah, Serious Sam 3: BFE had the epic invulnerable Arachnoid. One of many reasons why I love Croteam.

Last edited by JonLester, Nov. 14, 2013 at 16:34
Zeipher  Nov. 14, 2013 at 17:00

I liked Batman Arkham Asylum. You couldn't glide, and so many people were posting on the official forums for help. The general response was "In order to glide, it's a simple matter of buying an official version of the game.

theslickmeister  Nov. 15, 2013 at 08:33

Seems like this would make a good article in itself.... "The best booby traps in video games" :D

Quietus  Nov. 15, 2013 at 09:36

Agreed, theslickmeister. "Top Ten Tuesdays: Most Amusing Anti-Piracy Measures in Games".:D

stevenjameshyde  Nov. 15, 2013 at 09:50
Late  Nov. 15, 2013 at 11:04

Love them! :D

MikeBeaver  Nov. 15, 2013 at 23:28

Earthbound on the SNES had some epic protection didn't it? something about it wiping your save game and the VERY end of the game just after you had spent what? 50 -60 hours getting there? :p

LOL :)


Mike..

Trackbacks

Leave a Trackback from your own site

Email Address:

You don't need an account to comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.